Token-Curated Registry with Citation Graph

  • Kensuke Ito The University of Tokyo
  • Hideyuki Tanaka The University of Tokyo
Keywords: token-curated registry, mechanism design, peer prediction, PageRank, citation graph


In this study, we aim to incorporate the expertise of anonymous curators into a token-curated registry (TCR), a decentralized recommender system for collecting a list of high-quality content. This registry is important, because previous studies on TCRs have not specifically focused on technical content, such as academic papers and patents, whose effective curation requires expertise in relevant fields. To measure expertise, curation in our model focuses on both the content and its citation relationships, for which curator assignment uses the Personalized PageRank (PPR) algorithm while reward computation uses a multi-task peer-prediction mechanism. Our proposed CitedTCR bridges the literature on network-based and token-based recommender systems and contributes to the autonomous development of an evolving citation graph for high-quality content. Moreover, we experimentally confirm the incentive for registration and curation in CitedTCR using the simplification of a one-to-one correspondence between users and content (nodes).


Agarwal, A., Mandal, D., Parkes, D. C., Shah, N. “Peer Prediction with Heterogeneous Users.” In Proceedings of the 2017 ACM Conference on Economics and Computation ACM 81–98 (2017) https://doi:org/10:1145/3033274:3085127.

Asgaonkar, A., Krishnamachari, B. “Token Curated Registries-A Game Theoretic Approach.” arXiv (2018) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://www:arxiv:org/abs/1809:01756.

Balasanov, S. “TCR Design Flaws: Why Blockchain Needs Reputation.” Medium (accessed 15 April 2019) https://blog:relevant:community/tcr-design-flaws-why-blockchain-needs-reputation-c5771d97b210.

Brin, S., Page, L. “The Anatomy of a Large-Scale Hypertextual Web Search Engine.” Computer Networks and ISDN systems 30.1-7 107–117 (1998) https://doi:org/10:1016/S0169-7552(98)00110-X.

Bulkin, A. “Curate This: Token Curated Registries That Don’t Work.” Medium (accessed15 April 2019) https://blog:coinfund:io/curate-this-token-curated-registries-that-dont-work-d76370b77150.

Dasgupta, A., Ghosh, A. “Crowdsourced Judgement Elicitation with Endogenous Proficiency.” In Proceedings of the 22nd International Conference on World Wide Web ACM 319–330 (2013) https://doi:org/10:1145/2488388:2488417.

Faltings, B., Radanovic, G. Game Theory for Data Science: Eliciting Truthful Information. San Rafael: Morgan & Claypool Publishers (2017).

Gneiting, T., Raftery, A. E. “Strictly Proper Scoring Rules, Prediction, and Estimation.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 102.477 359–378 (2007) https://doi:org/10:1198/016214506000001437.

Goel, N., Filos-Ratsikas, A., Faltings, B. “Decentralized Oracles via Peer-Prediction in the Presence of Lying Incentives.” (2019) Presented at the 14th Tinbergen Institute Conference “Bayesian Crowd” at Erasmus University Rotterdam, 24 June 2019, https://lia:epfl:ch/~goel/upload/doc/papers/2019/goel_outside_incentives.pdf.

Goldin, M. “Token Curated Registries 1.1, 2.0 TCRs, New Theory, and Dev Updates.” Medium (accessed 3 April 2019) https://medium:com/@ilovebagels/token-curated-registries-1-1-2-0-tcrs-new-theory-and-dev-updates-34c9f079f33d.

Goldin, M. “Token-Curated Registries 1.0.” Medium (accessed 2 April 2019) https://medium:com/@ilovebagels/token-curated-registries-1-0-61a232f8dac7.

Gori, M., Pucci, A. “Research Paper Recommender Systems: A Random-Walk Based Approach.” In 2006 IEEE/WIC/ACM International Conference on Web Intelligence (WI 2006 Main Conference Proceedings) (WI’06) IEEE 778–781 (2006) https://doi:org/10:1109/WI:2006:149.

Gui, G., Hortacsu, A., Tudon, J. “A Memo on the Proof-of-Stake Mechanism.” arXiv (2018) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://arxiv:org/abs/1807:09626.

Haveliwala, T. H. “Topic-Sensitive Pagerank.” In Proceedings of the 11th International Conference on World Wide Web ACM 517–526 (2002) https://doi:org/10:1145/511446:511513.

Hemenway Falk, B., Tsoukalas, G. “Token-Weighted Crowdsourcing.” SSRN (accessed 3 December 2019) https://dx:doi:org/10:2139/ssrn:3295811.

Hirsch, J. E. “An Index to Quantify an Individual’s Scientific Research Output.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102.46 16569–16572 (2005) https://doi:org/10:1073/pnas:0507655102.

Jurca, R., Faltings, B. “Enforcing Truthful Strategies in Incentive Compatible Reputation Mechanisms.” In International Workshop on Internet and Network Economics Springer 268–277 (2005) https://doi:org/10:1007/11600930 26.

Küçüktunç, O., Saule, E., Kaya, K., Çatalyürek, Ü. V. “Recommendation on Academic Networks Using Direction Aware Citation Analysis.” arXiv (2012) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://arxiv:org/abs/1205:1143.

Liu, X., Suel, T., Memon, N. “A Robust Model for Paper Reviewer Assignment.” In Proceedings of the 8th ACM Conference on Recommender Systems ACM 25–32 (2014) https://doi:org/10:1145/2645710:2645749.

Lockyer, M. “Token Curated Registry (TCR) Design Patterns.” Medium (accessed 3 April 2019) https://hackernoon:com/token-curated-registry-tcr-design-patterns-4de6d18efa15.

Mandal, D., Leifer, M., Parkes, D. C., Pickard, G., Shnayder, V. “Peer Prediction With Heterogeneous Tasks.” arXiv (2016) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://arxiv:org/abs/1612:00928.

Miller, N., Resnick, P., Zeckhauser, R. “Eliciting Informative Feedback: The Peer-Prediction Method.” Management Science 51.9 1359–1373 (2005) https://doi:org/10:1287/mnsc:1050:0379.

Nakamoto, S. “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System.” (2008) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://bitcoin:org/bitcoin:pdf.

Nisan, N., Roughgarden, T., Tardos, E., Vazirani, V. V. Algorithmic Game Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press (2007).

No Author. “Gnosis Whitepaper.” (2017) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://gnosis:io/pdf/gnosis-whitepaper.pdf.

No Author. “NEM Technical Reference.” (2018) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://nem:io/wp-content/themes/nem/files/NEM_techRef.pdf.

No Author. “Token Curated Registries — Messari - Crypto News, Pricing, and Research.” Messari (2018) (accessed 15 April 2019) https://messari:io/resource/token-curated-registries.

Page, L., Brin, S., Motwani, R., Winograd, T. “The PageRank Citation Ranking: Bringing Order to the Web.” Stanford InfoLab (1999) (accessed 3 December 2019) http://ilpubs:stanford:edu:8090/422/.

Peterson, J., Krug, J., Zoltu, M.,Williams, A. K., Alexander, S. “Augur: A Decentralized Oracle and Prediction Market Platform.” arXiv (2015) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://arxiv:org/abs/1501:01042.

Saleh, F. “Blockchain Without Waste: Proof-of-Stake.” SSRN (2018) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://dx:doi:org/10:2139/ssrn:3183935.

Shannon, P., et al. “Cytoscape: A Software Environment for Integrated Models of Biomolecular Interaction Networks.” Genome Research 13.11 2498–2504 (2003) https://doi:org/10:1101/gr:1239303.

Shnayder, V., Agarwal, A., Frongillo, R., Parkes, D. C. “Informed Truthfulness in Multi-Task Peer Prediction.” In Proceedings of the 2016 ACM Conference on Economics and Computation ACM 179–196 (2016) https://doi:org/10:1145/2940716:2940790.

Token Curated Registry. “The Token Curated Registry Reading List.” Medium (accessed 15 April 2019) https://medium:com/@tokencuratedregistry/the-token-curated-registry-whitepaper-bd2fb29299d6.

Tsai, M.-H., Aggarwal, C., Huang, T. “Ranking in Heterogeneous Social Media.” In Proceedings of the 7th ACM International Conference on Web Search and Data Mining ACM 613–622 (2014) https://doi:org/10:1145/2556195:2556254.

Wang, Y. L., Krishnamachari, B. “Enhancing Engagement in Token-Curated Registries via an Inflationary Mechanism.” arXiv (2018) (accessed 3 December 2019) https://www:arXiv:org/abs/1811:09680.

Witkowski, J., Parkes, D. C. “Peer Prediction Without a Common Prior.” In Proceedings of the 13th ACM Conference on Electronic Commerce ACM 964–981 (2012) https://doi:org/10:1145/2229012:2229085.

Research Articles